Toshiba HD-A1 DVD Player Review
Toshiba's new HD-DVD player has hit the shelves, at an initial price of around $500. Several reviewers give it
mixed marks, with the picture quality rated excellent and several of the features rated less than ideal.
On the plus side, the player sells for half to one-third the expected price for Blu-ray machines, due in the
summer of 2006. True, $500 is still pricey for a DVD player, but at more than four times the displayed number of
pixels, resolution on an appropriate HDTV will dazzle even the most blasé viewers.
Also, to Toshiba's credit they hit their expected delivery date so that early adopters can judge for themselves
whether the premium over a standard DVD player is justified.
Beyond price and delivery, a full line of ports is available on the machine, including not just the expected
component and HDMI (High Definition Multimedia Interface) ports but also an Ethernet connection.
The HDMI port is essential for getting the highest quality out of HD discs and standard DVDs. Also, if the
studios follow through on copy-protection, it will be required in order to play the discs in high definition.
Other features and behavior may or may not be acceptable, depending on the consumer's level of patience with
first generation technology.
Since HD-DVD machines are as much a PC as a video player, they are slower and have many of the possible glitches
that computers are prone to. The machines have an in built operating system running on a Pentium 4, 2GHz chip. It
is rumored to be running a version of Linux, but with Microsoft strongly supporting HD-DVD over Blu-ray that may
change, if it's even true.
Any operating system, even running off a chip, is going to be slower to perform some functions than dedicated
electronics. But it does open the door to increased functionality with a simple download through the Ethernet
That may explain why the unit takes more than half a minute to display an inserted disc and why menu movement is
sometimes a little slow.
Some reviewers had trouble with HDMI errors. They would hook up the cables and receive no picture, even after
re-booting the unit, requiring the cables to be reconnected. That could be loose or defective cables, a
semi-defective unit or a firmware error correctable via an update. Or, it may be a design flaw. There's no way to
tell at this early stage.
In any case, it is something consumers should be wary of. You do not want to have to hassle with your DVD player
the way you have become used to doing with your PC.
Reviewers also gave poor marks to the remote, citing it as large and illogically arranged. Those things are
often a matter of taste. What is not a matter of taste are the semi functional buttons that have to be repeatedly
pressed. That could be a weak signal from poor batteries, but that is unlikely for a new unit.
Back on the upside again, there is that undeniably excellent picture. Even standard DVDs look better, but that
may be as much due to the HDTV used. In any case, the HD-DVD player is at least performing the minimum required by
displaying standard DVDs in better than standard quality.
Sound quality, too, on the new unit is excellent - reproducing full Dolby quality. However, depending on your
set, you may need to do some 're-engineering' to hook up your system differently to obtain the optimum sound.
Whether the units are 'ready for prime-time' is to some degree a matter of interest in HD material. Given that
Sony is preparing to release a $600 Playstation that will play Blu-ray discs, games and support downloads consumers
may want to wait and see.